Quantum mechanics, computers cannot predict molecular energy.

Home page
Quantum computers useless in drugs.
Simulating largest atoms is fake.

IBM hybrid quantum-classical computer scam.

Quantum mechanics is useless, cannot solve its Schrödinger equations nor predict energy of any multi-electron atoms, whether (impractical) quantum computers (= disguised as deceptive hybrid quantum computer = just classical computer ) or classical computers are used, contrary to hypes.

(Fig.1)   For unsolvable Schrödinger equations, quantum mechanics has to choose fake trial wavefunctions out of infinite choices, which is also useless, time-consuming, cannot predict anything.

Useless quantum mechanics cannot predict energy.

Quantum mechanics relies on the impractical Schrödinger equations that are unsolvable and unable to predict any multi-electron atomic energy.

Quantum mechanics relies on the impractical Schrödinger equation consisting of electrons' kinetic and Coulomb potential energy equal to total (= Hamiltonian H ) energy E.

This Schrödinger equation, which is the only tool of quantum mechanics, is unsolvable and unable to predict energy of any multi-electron atoms or molecules.

Quantum mechanics just chooses fake solutions.

Quantum mechanics can only choose fake trial wavefunctions (= fake solutions ) for unsolvable Schrödinger equations out of infinite free choices, which is impractical, too time-consuming, unable to predict anything.

For unsolvable Schrödinger equations, quantum mechanics can only choose fake trial wavefunctions (= fake solutions ) or basis set functions out of infinite free choices ( this or this-4~5th-paragraphs ) and infinite free parameters ( this-p.9-last ) to find ones giving the lowest (fake) total energy E, which quantum mechanical approximate variational methods called Hartree-Fock and configuration interaction (= CI ) take infinite time, so impractical, unable to predict anything ( this or this-p.2~p.3 ).

This or this-p.4-1st-paragraph says  -- No quantum mechanical prediction
"Notice that this (quantum approximate variational) method cannot give us an idea of difference between the upper bound we calculate using the trial wave function and the actual ground state energy... So we do Not have any way of knowing how good or how bad our (chosen) trial wave function is. The variational method also does Not tell us what kind of a trial function we must choose"

Hybrid computers are classical computers.

Recent deceptive hybrid quantum computer methods (= QSCI, SQD ) for calculating molecular energies are conducted by classical computers based on empirically-chosen fake trial wavefunctions with No quantum computation nor quantum mechanical prediction.

For today's useless error-prone quantum computers, companies such as IBM, IonQ, and universities try to make deceptive hybrid quantum-classical computer methods (= just classical computers ) such as VQE, quantum-selected configuration interaction (= QSCI ) equal to sample-based quantum dianonalization (= SQD ).

↑ All of these hybrid quantum computer methods such as QSCI, SQD are based on impractical quantum variational configuration interaction (= CI,  this or this-p.5 ) for unsolvable Schrodinger equations, which just chooses fake trial wavefunctions (= Slater determinants, this or this-p.3 ) that cannot predict anything.

↑ In all these deceptive hybrid computer methods, actual calculations of molecular energy (= Hamiltonian ) based on empirically-chosen fake trial wavefunctions (= called ansatz ) for unsolvable Schrödinger equations were conducted by classical computers ( this-p.4 ) with No quantum computation nor quantum mechanical prediction.

Quantum computers give only random numbers.

In the deceptive hybrid quantum-classical methods (= QSCI = SQD ), the useless quantum computers can get only random numbers called sampling from empirically-guessed wavefunctions' parameters called ansatz, and all energy calculations were conducted by classical computers with No quantum computation nor quantum mechanical prediction.

In the recent deceptive hybrid quantum-classical computer methods called quantum-selected configuration interaction (= QSCI) equal to sample-based quantum diagonalization (= SQD ), today's useless quantum computers could only get random meaningless numbers (= sampling ) from parameters empirically guessed fake trial wavefunctions called " ansatz (= whose energies must be calculated by classical computers )"

↑ So No quantum computation nor quantum mechanical prediction in the current hybrid quantum computation of molecular energy.

Classical computers must calculate all.

Instead of today's error-prone useless quantum computers, classical computers must perform all calculations of molecular energy in the deceptive hybrid computing methods.

In the deceptive hybrid computing methods, classical computers have to calculate and find coefficient free parameters (= c ) giving the lowest (fake) total (= Hamiltonian ) energy of some molecules in the process called diagonalization ( this or this-(61),  this-(7.10),  this or this-lower-equation.56 ) within artificially-chosen trial wavefunctions by quantum mechanical variational methods, which cannot predict anything.

This-p.4 says  -- No quantum computation
"The quantum selected configuration interaction (QSCI) method (= SQD ).. The central idea of the method is that some approximate ground state is prepared on a quantum computer (= called ansatz empirically guessed first ), which is then used to draw samples corresponding to determinants in the computational basis. The CI Hamiltonian is then classically diagonalized"

"First, since the quantum device is only used for selection, while energies are obtained classically (= molecular energy must be calculated by classical computers )"

Artificially-chosen fake trial wavefunctions = ansatz.

Due to useless quantum mechanics that cannot predict anything, the deceptive hybrid quantum computing methods have to empirically guess fake trial wavefunctions called ansatz to artificially get desired molecular energy values.

This-p.2-left-C. says  -- No quantum mechanical prediction
"In quantum computing, an Ansatz refers to a (fake) trial wavefunction (= artificially- chosen ) or trial state used as a starting point for approximations or optimizations. It is a parameterized quantum state that serves as an educated guess (= empirically-chosen, so No quantum mechanical prediction ) for solving a particular problem, such as finding the ground state of a quantum system."

"Selecting an appropriate ansatz is crucial in quantum algorithm design, as it significantly impacts the accuracy of the outcomes."

This-p.4-right-last~p.5 says  -- Empirical, No quantum prediction
"It has been empirically observed that the parameters derived from CCSD yield good choices to run SQD experiments in noisy quantum processors"

IBM fake hybrid quantum computing

The recent IBM's deceptive hybrid quantum computation of molecular energy relied on artificially-chosen fake trial wavefunctions (= ansatz ) whose energy was calculated by classical computers with No quantum computation nor quantum mechanical prediction.

The recent IBM research in 2025 also used this deceptive hybrid method called SQD (= QSCI ) to seemingly get energies of water and methane molecular dimers with No quantum computation nor quantum mechanical prediction.

↑ This or this-IBM hybrid research paper (= this-last-link ) ↓

p.1-abstract says  -- Fake hybrid quantum computer
"We use a sample-based quantum diagonalization (SQD) approach (= just classical computer method, No quantum computation nor quantum mechanical prediction ) to simulate the potential energy surfaces (PES) of the water and methane dimers,.. We benchmark our quantum simulations (27- and 36-qubit circuits).. 54 qubits (= one qubit can take only 0 or 1 value, so still Not a quantum computer )"

p.4-right-2nd-paragraph says  -- Classical computer guessed parameters
"Parametrization of LUCJ circuits (= empirically-guessed initial qubits' state called ansatz ) based on the t2-amplitudes, obtained from CCSD calculations on classical computers (= quantum computer is useless ), yields electron configuration distributions corresponding to total energies"

p.6-right-2nd-paragraph says  -- No quantum computer advantage
"Finally, we would like to note that the demonstration of quantum advantage on real quantum hardware in electronic structure simulations, to our knowledge, has Not been achieved by any research group yet, neither with SQD, nor any other quantum accelerated techniques and, as such, remains one of the most challenging tasks in quantum computing"

IBM hybrid quantum advantage cheating debunked

In the deceptive IBM hybrid quantum computer, their useless quantum computers could only randomly sample parameters with No quantum advantage nor quantum computation.

↑ This research' reviewers debunked IBM fake quantum advantage,  this or this ↓

p.2-last says  -- Classically chosen parameters
"1. The workflow, as far as I can understand, consists of: (i) a classical calculation (CCSD on a active space = ) that (ii) informs the choice of the parameters in the LUCJ wavefunction (= ansatz ) prepared on the quantum hardware"

p.3-1st-paragraph says  -- No quantum computer advantage
"The quantum part of the algorithm (iii) is therefore used to extract (= randomly sample ) electronic configurations with a probability related to how much they were represented in the initial wavefunction (= guessed ansatz ), that in turn was informed by the initial classical calculation. I think it should be made clear what is the practical advantage in extracting such configurations from the quantum hardware rather than directly from the initial classical wavefunction"

p.30-5th-paragraph says  -- IBM admits No advantage
"We agree that currently we do Not have sufficient data to demonstrate the possibility of quantum advantage in simulations of non-covalent interactions."

p.32-1st-paragraph says  -- No hybrid SQD advantage
"We have now gone through the rebuttal and the revised manuscript. We still do Not see answers to crucial questions we asked at the first review round: Why encoding the LUCJ wavefunction on a quantum computer and extracting from there should be more efficient than extracting classically"

"In particular it is still not clear if the SQD leads to a more efficient sampling of the wavefunction w.r.t the classical approach."

IBM with No hybrid quantum SQD advantage.

IBM hybrid quantum computation of molecular energy was conducted by classical computers based on empirically chosen fake trial wavefunctions' parameters with No quantum mechanical prediction.

The recent IBM-Riken's research on the deceptive hybrid SQD methods published in Science ( this-last-paragraph ) for calculating some molecules such as N2 heavily relied on classical computers calculating the energies from artificially-chosen trial wavefunctions with No quantum computation nor quantum mechanical prediction

 

to

Feel free to link to this site.