Schrödinger equation  is false.

  Top

Schrödinger's atom = parallel worlds !?

[ An electron is everywhere at the same time in quantum world ? ]

(Fig.1)  Schrödinger's hydrogen = an electron everywhere !?

Quantum mechanics uses Schrödinger equation, where a single electron can be everywhere at the same time in parallel worlds.

Quantum mechanics tries to apply these unreal parallel worlds to all atoms !

But this "parallel-world" nature of Schrödinger equation does Not work in multi-electron atoms.

Here we prove quantum mechanics is wrong.

 

No electron  in quantum mechanics ?

[ There is No clear electron, No motion in Schrödinger atom ! ]

(Fig.2)  Just vague electron cloud in quantum atom ↓

Quantum mehanics can not descibe real electrons.
It gives only vague electron cloud spreading over all space to infinity.

Strangely, though Schrödinger equation has kinetic energy, its electron is Not moving "realistically" !

This unphysical nature of quantum mechanics = "No clear electron, No electron's motion" causes serious problem in multi- electron atoms.

Because it's unreal.

 

Electron "everywhere"  in quantum mechanics !

[ Schrödinger wavefunction spreads all space ← electron everywhere !? ]

(Fig.3)  ↓ Only one-electron hydrogen has solution in quantum mechanics.

Only one-electron hydrogen atom has solution in Schrödinger equation.

Hydrogen wavefunction spreads all space, so in all space, the electron's total energy must be conserved at constant E.

Coulomb energy term must be cancelled out by kinetic energy to give constant total energy in all space.

This is impossible in multi-electron Schrödinger atoms.

 

Quantum mechanical Helium can Not find exact solution.

[ Schrödinger probability wavefunction of each electron must always spread all over the space = a single electron is everywhere !? ]

(Fig.4)   Two hydrogen wavefunctions → Helium ?

All Schrödinger equations for multi-electron atoms such as two-electron helium are known to be unsolvable.

Basically, quantum mechanics tries to waste time in choosing fake approximate solution or trial wavefunction as a fictitious helium wavefunction (= the simplest one is a fititious helium wavefunction consists of two hydrogen 1s atomic wavefunctions ) and integrating it to obtain fake average total energy E instead of solving the unsolvable Schrödinger equation for helium.

We can prove Schrödinger equations for multi-electron atoms such as helium can never find true solutions, no matter what fake trial wavefunctions are chosen.

This is due to the always-spreading probability wavefunction of quantum mechanics where a single electron must unrealistically exist everywhere regardless of the other electrons' positions.

 

Distance between two electrons of Schrödinger Helium is unrealistically changeable.

[ Distance (= |r1-r2| ) between two electrons (= e1 and e2 ) can be changed independently of other distance variables r1 and r2. ]

(Fig.5)  ↓ Three Coulomb terms can be changed independently !?

Quantum mechanical Coulomb potential energy terms can be changed independently.

These three Coulomb potential energy terms are Coulomb attractive energy between the electron-1 and the helium nucleus (= distance r1 ), Coulomb attractive energy between the electron-2 and the nucleus (= distance r2 ), and Coulomb repulsive energy between two electrons-1 and -2 (= distance |r1-r2| or r12 ).

In the upper figure, we can freely change the position of the electron-2 (= e2 in a circular way around the nucleus ) so that only the distance (= |r1-r2| or r12 ) between two electrons e1 and e2 is changed while other distance (= r1 ) between electron-1 (=e1 )-nucleus and the distance (= r2 ) between electron-2-nucleus are unchanged.

This means we can freely change only one Coulomb repulsive energy term between two electrons (= only e2/4πε |r1-r2| Coulomb energy can be changed ) while keeping other two Coulomb attractive energy terms unchanged (= = -e2/4πε r1 and -e2/4πε r2 are unchanged and fixed )

 

Each Coulomb potential energy term is freely changeable in unscientific Schrödinger's Helium.

[ Artificially changing only one variable r1 ( or r2 ) independently or changing only one Coulomb potential energy term independently is possible in quantum mechanical helium. ]

(Fig.5')  ↓ Only one variable or distance r1 (or r2 ) can be freely changed in quantum mechanical helium atoms.

As shown in Fig.5', we can freely change only one variable or distance (= r1 ) between the electron-1 and the helium nucleus, while other distance variables (= r2 and |r1-r2 | ) are kept unchanged.

So in quantum mechanical helium, three distance variables and their three Coulomb energy terms are all free parameters changeable independently of the other two variables or Coulomb potential energy terms, which unscientific quantum mechanical atomic property causes serious problems, and disproves quantum mechanics.

 

Reason why Schrödinger equations for multi-electron atoms or Helium can never have true solutions.

Helium must split into three unreal hydrogens, if Helium had exact solution for Schrödinger equation, this is impossible, so quantum mechanics is false.

(Fig.6)  ↓ Helium = three unreal hydrogens ? ← Schrödinger is wrong !

Quantum mechanical electron can exist everywhere.

Unphysical quantum mechanical spreading probability wavefunction allows each electron to always exist in all places simultaneously.

For unsolvable Schrodinger equation for helium with two electrons, physicists often choose fake helium trial wavefunction consisting of two hydrogen spreading probability wavefunctions.

Quantum mechanical wavefunction expressing probability of finding an electron in each place must always spread in large area, because sharp wavefunction (= short de Broglie wavelength ) increases electron's kinetic energy unrealistically, which disagrees with actual atomic energy.

So due to these spreading probability wavefunctions, two electrons of quantum mechanical helium can exist in all places independently from each other's positions, which enable three Coulomb potential energy terms of helium (= between electron-1-nucleus (= r1 ), electron-2-nucleus (= r2 ), electron1-electron-2 (= |r1-r2|) ) to change independently of each other.

Quantum mechanics cannot have true helium conserving energy

For quantum mechanics to have true solution for unsolvable helium Schrodinger equation, it must split into three unreal independent hydrogen atoms, which is impossible, so quantum mechanics is wrong.

As a result, for quantum mechanical helium's Schrodinger equation to have true solution with the constant conserved total energy E in any electrons' positions, chosen helium trial wavefunctions's kinetic energy terms (= caused by second derivative of wavefunctions ) must cancel three Coulomb potential energy terms independently.

↑ This is as if fake helium trial wavefunction contains three unreal independent hydrogen atoms, which is impossible.

So quantum mechanics can never find true helium solution for unsolvable Schrodinger equations.

 

Only Schrödinger's hydrogen has true solution.

Quantum mechanical Schrödinger equation has true solution only for hydrogen atom which can get the constant conserved total energy E by kinetic energy canceling Coulomb potential energy terms, which is impossible in any multi-electron atoms.

(Fig.H)  Only Schrodinger equation for H atom has true wavefunction solution giving the constant total energy E in any electron's positions.

Only Schrödinger equation for a hydrogen (= H ) atom can have true solution.

Schrödinger equation for H atom can find true solution whose kinetic energy cancels Coulomb energy terms to give constant total energy E.

Only Schrödinger equation for one electron hydrogen atom is known to be solvable, which energy values "accidentally" agreed with Bohr's realistic hydrogen atom.

Total atomic energy E, which is the sum of electron's kinetic energy (= expressed as the second-order derivative ) and Coulomb potential energy, must be always constant and conserved.

In this solvable hydrogen atoms, we can find true wavefunction that gives the constant conserved total energy E in any electron's positions where variables of kinetic energy (= obtained by differentiating the wavefunction ) and Coulomb energy terms are canceled to give only constant E energy value ( this p.1-last,  this p.2 ).

Schrödinger's helium can never have true solution.

Helium Schrödinger equation can never find true solution whose kinetic energy cancels Coulomb energy to give constant total energy E.

(Fig.6')  Quantum mechanics is wrong, unable to find true solutions for multi-electron Schrödinger equations.

Helium Schrödinger equation can never find true solution

Kinetic energy including two-variable terms cannot cancel Coulomb energy's one-variable terms to give the constant total energy E.  ← Helium Schrödinger equation is unsolvable.

Unfortunately, No Schrödinger equations for multi-electron atoms such as helium are solvable.

For unsolvable Schrodinger equation for helium or multi-electron atoms, physicists have to choose fake trial wavefunctions out of infinite choices.  ← No matter what (fake) trial wavefunctions (or basis set functions ) are chosen, these wavefunctions can never be true solutions of Schrodinger equations for helium or multi-electron atoms, which fact disproves quantum mechanics.

Helium wavefunction must contain three variables r1 (= distance between electron-1 and helium nucleus ), r2 (= distance between electron-2 and nucleus ) and |r1 - r2| (= distance between two electrons-1 and 2 ) for the kinetic energy terms (= obtained by differentiating the wavefunction ) to cancel the three variables of the helium Coulomb potential energy terms consisting of 1/r1, 1/r2, and 1/|r1 - r2| for getting the constant total energy E regardless of two electrons' positions of r1 and r2.

↑ This helium true solution can never be found, as shown in this and this.  ← The helium kinetic energy terms (= second derivative of the wavefunction ) always include a term mixing two variables of r1, |r1-r2| that can Not cancel variables of Coulomb energy (= each Coulomb energy term always consists of only one variable 1/r1 or 1/r2 or 1/|r1-r2| ) to get the constant conserved helium total energy E.

As a result, Quantum mechanics or Schrodinger equations can never find true solutions (= cannot give the constant conserved total energy E in any electrons' positions ) for any multi-electron atoms or molecules, no matter how many terms and parameters are used in artificially-chosen (fake) trial wavefunctions.

Quantum mechanics is wrong. Only Bohr's realistic helium can conserve energy.

The only way to conserve total energy of helium is two electrons constantly moving dependently on each other's position like real Bohr's helium.

↑ Quantum mechanical (unrealistic) electrons' probability wavefunctions must always spread over all space (= if an electron is localized in only one point, whose acute de Broglie wavefunction drastically increases kinetic energy to infinity, giving wrong total energy ).

↑ So two electrons of the unphysical quantum mechanical helium atom can exist in any places in large area of their spreading probability wavefunctions independently from each other (= helium fake trial wavefunction often consists of two hydrogen atomic spreading probability wavefunctions ).  ← Three Coulomb potential energy terms of the helium can be changed independently from each other.

So all these three Coulomb potential energy terms or variables must be completely canceled out to be zero by kinetic energy to get the constant conserved total energy E in all two electrons' positions in the unphysical quantum mechanical helium atom, which is proven impossible, so quantum mechanics is wrong.

As a result, to conserve total energy of the helium, two electrons of the helium must be constantly moving and avoiding each other like real Bohr's helium, which changes three Coulomb potential energy terms dependetly on each other.

Only the realistic Bohr's helium atoms with two perpendicular orbits can give true helium's solution with the constant conserved exact total energy E in helium's two electrons' all positions (= Coulomb forces in any electrons' positions can be calculated by computers at short time intervals to conserve the constant total energy E in any electrons' positions along the orbits. )

If quantum mechanical Schrodinger equations have true solutions for multi-electron atoms (= which is impossible though ), the conserved total energy E must be constant in all multiple electrons' positions in all space, in which case, the realistic Bohr's helium atom conserving total energy in any two electrons' positions is also possible (= so Bohr's helium atom is definitely proven right, able to conserve the constant total energy in all electrons' positions along the orbits ).

Schrödinger equation for Helium can never have true solution.

(Fig.6'')  Helium kinetic energy terms containing two variables cannot cancel Coulomb potential terms (= each term contains only one variable ), so Schrödinger equation for helium can never have true solution giving the constant conserved total energy E.

Kinetic energy's two-variable terms cannot cancel Coulomb energy's one-variable terms.

As shown in the upper figure, the helium kinetic energy terms (= second-order derivative ) always include terms consisting of two different variables of r1 and |r1-r2| (or r2, |r1-r2| ) which can Not be canceled by helium Coulomb potential energy terms where each Coulomb energy term consists of only one variable r1 or r2 or |r1-r2|.

In the upper figure, Schrödinger equation's kinetic energy (= derivative ) acts on exponential functions of some (chosen) Helium wavefunction's term of the highest order, which gives two-variable terms that cannot be canceled by Coulomb potential energy terms or by any other kinetic energy terms ( due to the highest-order term ).  ← cannot get the constant conserved total energy E.

↑ These two-variable terms of kinetic energy cannot be canceled between x, y, z derivative terms due to two different variables (= x1, x1-x2 ) mixed

As a result, Schrödinger equations for helium or multi-electron atoms can never be solved nor have true analytical solutions, showing quantum mechanics is false.

 

Only Bohr's helium with two moving electrons is right.

Unlike unreal quantum mechanics that cannot have true helium wavefunction, only real Bohr's helium with two moving electrons is right, conserving total energy in any electrons' positions.

(Fig.7)  Each electron independent → Coulomb term independent → unreal atom

Only Bohr's helium with two moving electrons is real.

Quantum mechanics is proven wrong, unable to have true solutions for helium Schrodinger equation.

The only real helium conserving accurate total energy is Bohr's helium with two moving electrons whose positions, velocity and de Broglie wave must be precisely computed at short time intervals to conserve total energy in any electrons' positions.

↑ In this real Bohr's helium with two precisely moving electrons, three Coulomb potential energy terms are changed dependently on each other's positions (= which calculations need computers ) unlike the incorrect quantum mechanical helium where three Coulomb potential energy terms must unrealistically be changed independently due to spreading probability wavefunctions.

As a result, quantum mechanics is officially proven wrong in multi-electron atoms that cannot have true constant conserved total energy.

 

to

Feel free to link to this site.