$B!V$3$l$+$iO@J8$r=q$/
$B=PHG8e$N?J9T>u67(B
$B
$B?J9T>u67%[!<%`(B
4/30
($BEZ(B) $B$N?JJb!!2f$,2H$G4?7^2q(B
$B:#F|$O2f$,2H$G?7B48&@8$N4?7^2q$r9T$&!#$H$$$&$o$1$GD+;T$G!"$b$C$A!(B)$B!&$^$7$c$+$HBT$A9g$o$;$F!"A/5{$d=UK~:\;3:Z(B
$B$J$I$rGc$C$?!#2f$,2H$KLa$j!"(B4$B?M$r@8EL$K5{$*$m$7$N9V=,2q$r$7$?!#rM$H0s$r$*$m$7$FLc$C$?$N$@!#$3$3$G0U30$J:MG=$,H/8+$5$l$?!#$A$c$s$+$_(B
($B2>(B)$B$,e
$B40`z$G$"$k!#(B1$BEY$d$C$?$3$H$O$"$k$H$$$&!#$7$+$7!";d$N9V=,$r2?2s$b
$B8=>le$K!"6'4o$H8+$i$l$kJqCz$,$"$k!#$^!"=i$a$F$J$iIaDL$O$3$&$@!#(B
$B!!$=$N8e!"3'$b=8$^$C$F$-$F!"%,%l%C%H$N=`Hw$@$N$r$7$?!#;d$b!"=U$NOB$(J*$H$*?;$7$r:n$C$?!#$=$7$F(B17$B;~H>$/$i$$$+$i2q$r;O$a$?!#$^$:$O3'9g:n(B
$B$N%,%l%C%H!#Ln:Z$?$C$W$j$GH~L#$7$+$C$?!#>F$1$k$N$rBT$D4V$K!";dF$$$FC!$-$K$7$?$N$@!#>F$-N)$F:G9b$@$M!#$=$N8e$O!"K\KnBg%H%m!&%$%5%-!&rM!&0s!&%\%?%s%(%S$N;I?H$K!"rV$N1v>F$-(B
$B$K!"5(@a$N$*?;$7$K!"$J$N$h$A$c$s!&$"$*$d$J:n$N=P=A4,$-Mq$K!":F$S%,%l%C%H$K!"%P%i%b%s$i:n$N9|@yL_(B$BFy@yL_$,$+$J$j:.F~(B$B$K(B
$B$H!"H~L#$7$$J*$r$?$/$5$sD:$$$?!#$+$/$7$F!"3Z$7$/H~L#$7$$2q$r(B12$B;~H>$/$i$$$^$GB3$1$?!#;d$ONc$K$h$C$F!"8eH>ItJ,$N5-21$,$"$^$j$J$$!#$A$c$s(B
$B$+$_(B($B2>(B)$B$N2>$,!#(B
$B!!$H$$$&$o$1$G!"$^$7$c$+!&$J$N$h$A$c$s!&$A$c$s$+$_!&$"$*$d$J!"
$B%Y%,%k%?@gBf(B0-2$B%5%,%sD;@4!#=`Hw$r$7$J$,$i%F%l%S$G8+$?!#l$5$;$F$7$^$C$?!#$$$C$?$$!"$I$&$$$&88$N1GA|$r8+$F$$$?$N$+!"$"$N
$B!!$+$?$d$^$5$+$NHaJs$b!#%Y%,%k%?@gBf%l%G%#!<%9(B0-1$B0K2l%U%C%H%\!<%k%/%i%V$/%N0l!#;n9gFbMF$OA4A3$o$+$i$J$$!#DK$9$.$kGT@o$G$"$k!#(B
4/29
($B6b(B) $B$N?JJb!!L@F|$O0K2l@o$HD;@4@o(B
$B%Y%,%k%?@gBf%l%G%#!<%9$OL@F|!"E(CO$G0K2l%U%C%H%\!<%k%/%i%V$/%N0l$HF.$&(B(13$B;~;n9g3+;O(B)$B!#E(CO$H$$$($I$-$C$A$j>!$C$F!"
$B!!CK;R$OL@F|!"%f%"%F%C%/%9%?%8%"%`@gBf$K%5%,%sD;@4$r7^$(7b$D(B(14$B;~;n9g3+;O(B)$B!#(B4$BO"GTCf$N2f$,%/%i%V$G$"$k!#L@F|$3$=>!$C$F!">e>:5$N.$K>h(B
$B$m$&!#$J$K$7$m!"Ii=}$N$?$a(B1$B%v7n0J>eN%C&$7$F$$$?(BMF$BNB$,L@F|$N;n9g$GI|3h$9$k$N$@!#NB$H$H$b$K>!Mx$rDO$_
$B!!L@F|$N;n9g!"$b$A$m$s;d$b;2@o$9$k$H=q$-$?$$$H$3$m$G$"$k$,!"$J$s$H7g>l$G$"$k!#L@F|!"?7B48&@8$N4?7^2q$r2f$,2H$G9T$&$N$@!#4?7^2q$NF|Dx$r7h(B
$B$a$?$B$B$r65$($k$?$a$K!"F|DxJQ99$9$k$3$H$b9M$($?!#$7$+$7!"F|Dx(B
$B$N:FD4@0$bFq$7$$$HD|$a$F$7$^$C$?!#?j$($?$J$"!
$B8aA0Cf$O%l%G%#!<%9$NN}=,$r8+$K9T$C$?!#;~4VJQ99$K$J$C$F$$$F!"Ce$$$?$H$-$K$O=*$o$C$F$$$?!#A*$BL@F|$N4?7^2q$N$?$a$NGc$$=P$7$r$7$h$&$HD+;T$K9T$C$?!#Csl$K4/28
($BLZ(B) $B$N?JJb!!$I$-$I$-$7$?(B
iPhone$B$r;H$&$h$&$K$J$C$F$b$&2?G/$+!#K\F|!"(BApple
Store$B$G=i$a$F$*Gc$$J*$r$7$?!#(BiPhone$BMQ$N?^4U%"%W%j!VLn$K:i$/2V!W$rGc$C$?$N$G$"$k!#=i$a$F$N$3$H$J$N$G!"$A$c$s$H9XF~$G$-$k$+$H$I(B
$B$-$I$-$7(B
$B$?!#$5$i$K$O!"9XF~$7$?$b$N$N%@%&%s%m!<%I=PMh$J$+$C$?$i$I$&$7$h$&$H$I$-$I$-$7$?!#$7$+$7[9M+$G$"$C$?!#$A$c$s$H%@%&%s%m!<%I=PMh$?!#$"$H$O!"(B
$B$;$C$+$/9XF~$7$?$N$K;H$o$J$+$C$?$i$I$&$7$h$&$H$I$-$I$-$9$k$N$_$G$"$k!#(B
$BK\G/EY=i$NO@J8%;%_%J!<$,$"$C$?!#$^$:$O%$%?%]%s$+$i!#$[$\A40w$,H/8@$7$F$/$l$F$h$+$C$?!#(B4$BG/@8$O!"%$%?%]%s$N$r
$B!!$=$N8e9V:B%;%_%J!<$,$"$C$?$i$7$$$N$@$1$l$I!"$9$C$+$j<:G0$7$F$$$?!#=P$k$N$rK:$l$?!#$9$^$J$$!#(B
4/27
($B?e(B) $B$N?JJb!!FsHV@y$8$,=P$?!*(B
$BK\F|$OBgJQ4n$P$7$$F|$G$"$k!#2<5-$N;d$?$A$NO@J8(B
Sakai, S. and Wakoh, H. (2014) Initial invasion of
gametophytic self-incompatibility alleles in the absence of tight
linkage between pollen and pistil S alleles. American
Naturalist 184:248-257.
$B$NFsHV@y$8$,=P$?$N$@!#(BSakai and Wakoh
(2014)$B$G;d$?$A$O!"<+2HITOB9g@-$N?J2=$K4X$7$FK`kEIT;W5D$JLdBj$,$"$k$H@$3&$G=i$a$F;XE&$7$?!#$=$7$F$=$NLdBj$r2r$/%b%G%k$rDs<($7$?!#(B
$B$H!"K\F|!"(B $B$^$C$?$/F1$8LdBj$r07$C$?O@J8$,=P$?!#(B
Schoen, D.J. and Roda, M. Selection of sporophytic and gametophytic
self-incompatibility in the absence of a superlocus. Evolution in
press.
$B<+J,$,;XE&$7$?LdBj$r2r@O$7$F$/$l$kO@J8$,=P$k$H$O!#$3$N$h$&$K!"?7$?$JF;$r@Z$jBs$$$F9T$/$3$H$,8&5f$NL5>e$N4n$S$G$"$k!#;d$O$3$l$^$G!"(B$BFs(B
$BHV@y$8$NO@J8$r?t!9=q$$$F$-$?(B$B$@$1$K!"$=$N8@MU$O=E$$!#(B
$B!!0l$D5$$KF~$i$J$$$N$O!"(BSchoen and
Roda$B$,!";d$?$A$,H/8+$7$?LdBj$r<+J,$?$A$,8+$D$1$?LdBj$+$N$h$&$K=q$$$F$$$kE@$G$"$k!#$3$l$b!"!V5DO@$N>e4/19$B$N?JJb(B$B;2>H(B) $BJ0A3!#(B
$B@8J*3X2J(B3$BG/@88~$1$N9V5A$r$7$?!#!V2V$N%8%l%s%^!W$H$$$&$*Bj$G$"$C$?!#$*$*$`$MG.?4$KD0$$$F$/$l$?$H;W$&!#$*CcDR$1$K$4HS$,$D$$$F$$$J(B
$B$$$H$$$&>W7b$OBg$-$+$C$?$G$"$m$&!#(B
$B
$B$"$*$d$J$N$?$a$N8+K\%W%m%0%i%`$r=q$$$F!"K\?M$K@bL@$7$?!#$=$7$F!"$3$&$$$&%W%m%0%i%`$r=q$$$F$_$F$H2]Bj$r=P$7$?!#4hD%$C$F$M!#
$B!!$=$N8e!"$^$7$c$+$H9=Fb;6:v!#$7$+$7L\Ev$F$N@8J*$O8+$D$+$i$:!#(B
4/26
($B2P(B) $B$N?JJb!!%N!<%H%Q%=%3%sFMA3;`(B
$BM$P$N$H$3$m(B
$B$GFMA3!"!V@\B3$,1>!9!W$H$$$&7Y9p2hLL$,=P$?!#$I$&$7$?$H$$$&$N$@!#%P%C%F%j!<$O7rA4!":#$^$G2?$NLdBj$b5/$3$5$:$KMh$?%Q%=%3%s$J$N$K!#5$$K$7$D(B
$B$D$b9V5A$r?J$a$?!#$7$+$7!"(B10$BJ,$[$I$7$F2hLL$,$9$&$C$H??$C0E$K$J$C$F$7$^$C$?!#F0:n2;$b>C$($?!#%-!<$rC!$/$J$I$7$F2sI|$r$O$+$k$bH?1~$J$7!#(B
$B$d$`$J$/!"G[I[MQ$N%W%j%s%H(B($B%9%i%$%I$r0u:~$7$?$b$N(B)$B$r;H$C$F9V5A$r?J$a$?!#?^=q4[0w$NJ}(B($B9V5A$NJd=u$r$7$F2<$5$C$F$$$k(B)$B$,EE8;%"%@%W%?$r(B
$B;}$C$F$-$F2<$5$C$?$N$G7R$2$F$_$?!#$7$+$7!"=
$B!!LdBj$,$b$&0l$D$"$C$?!#L@F|$N(B2$B%3%^L\$K!"@8J*3X2J(B3$BG/@88~$1$N9V5A$r$9$k$N$@!#$b$A$m$s!"$3$N%N!<%H%Q%=%3%s$r;H$&$D$b$j$@$C$?!#3X@8$N$rp
<.0001($B$?$$$X$s4m81(B)$B$G$"$k!#:#F|Cf$K$B$3$N$"$$$@N&=wr?$KO"$l$F9T$C$?$m!*(B
$B$"$*$d$J$H%b%G%k$NAjCL$r$7$?!#J}?K$,7h$^$C$?$N$G!";d$,!"$A$g$C$H$7$?8+K\$N%W%m%0%i%`$r=q$3$&$H;W$C$?!#$7$+$7;W$C$?$h$j$bFq$7$$!#(B
$B%W%m%0%i%`@_7W$NJ}8~@-$r7h$a$F$7$^$&$b$N$J$N$G!"$8$C$/$j9M$($?J}$,$h$$!#L@F|$b$d$k$3$H$K$7$?!#(B
$B<+J,$N%b%G%k2r@O$b?J$a$?!#(B2$B$D$N%b%G%k$r:n$C$F$$$F!"$"$k>r7o2<$G$ON>$78e!"?HD9$N$D$b$j$GBN=E$r7W$k$h$&$J4VH4$19T0Y$r(B
$B$d$C$F$$$k(B $B$3$H$K5$$E$-!"$I$C$HHh$l$k$H6&$K!"$H$b$+$/$b2r7h$7$F0BEH$7$?!#(B$B!V$O$$!"?HD97W$j$^$9!W!V!D!D!D(B
$B$=$j$c!"BN=E$@!W$H$$$&%3%s%H$rA[A|$7$F$_$h!#(B
4/25
($B7n(B) $B$N?JJb!!$3$l%l%](B2$B:}(B
$B2{$+$7$$J}$+$i%a!<%k$rD:$$$?!#85ElKLBg?^=q4[0w$N(BS$B$5$s$G$"$k!#%l%]!<%H:n@.K!$N9V5A$G$*@$OC$K$J$j!"!V(B$B$3$l$+$i%l%]!<%H!&B4O@$r=q$/$B!W$N<9I.;~$K$b$46(NOD:$$$?!#ElKLBg$GD9G/9T$C(B
$B$F$$$k%l%]!<%H:n@.K!$N9V5A$r85$K!"$3$l%l%]$r=q$$$?$N$@!#$=$N(BS$B$5$sBp$K$O!"$3$l%l%]$,(B2$B:}$"$k$H$$$&!#IaDL$N2HDm$O$"$C$F$b(B1$B:}$G$"$m$&!#(B2
$B:}$b$"$k$H$O!"(B$BF|K\$N2HDm$N6@(B$B$H;W$&!#$I$&$b$"$j$,$H$&$4$6$$$^$9!#(B
$B!!$A$J$_$K2f$,2H(B($B8&5f<<(B)$B$K$O!"$3$lO@$,(B26$B:}!"$3$l%l%]$,(B7$B:}!"$3$l3X$,(B7$B:}!"$3$l8&$,(B8$B:}$"$k!#$5$9$,$N=<
$BEl5~8^NX$N?7%(%s%V%l%`$,7h$^$C$?!#(BA$B0F$,:NMQ$5$l$?$=$&$@(B($B$3(B
$B$l(B)$B!#$&!<$`!#COL#$@$J$"!#(B$B$*Ar<0$N2VNX(B$B$H$7$F>~$i$l$F$$$F$b0cOB46$,$J$$!#(B
$B%b%G%k2r@O$r?J$a$?!#$7$+$7$&$^$/$$$+$J$$!#L$CN?t$,(B8$B$D$b$"$kO"N)J}Dx<0$r?tCME*$K2r$+$;$k$3$H$KL5M}$,$"$k$N$+!)(B
$B$b$&>/$78!F$$7$F!"B>$NJ}K!$b9M$($J$$$H$$$1$J$$!#(B
4/24
($BF|(B) $B$N?JJb!!$"$H(B1$BJ,$@$C$?$N$K(B
$B%Y%,%k%?@gBf(B 2-2 $B%t%#%C%;%k?@8M!#(B90+3$BJ,$H$$$&$H$3$m$GDI$$$D$+$l$F$7$^$C$?!#(B
$B!!E(CO$J$N$G(BCS$B$G1~1g$7$?!#N)$A>e$,$j$O!"6/NO(B2$B%H%C%W$rCf?4$K96$a9~$s$G$/$k?@8M$K$?$8$?$8$H$J$C$F$$$?!#A0H>(B7$BJ,$KAa!9$K<:E@!#$7$+$7!"A0(B
$BH>(B18$BJ,$K(BFW$BLnBt$,!"@gBf:G=i$H$J$k%7%e!<%H$GF@E@$r$"$2$?!#$3$l$,Bg$-$+$C$?!#$=$N8e$O8_3Q$NE83+$H$J$C$?!#$=$7$F8eH>(B27$BJ,!"(BMF$BT|G8$,(B
$B%4!<%kA0$GH?E>%7%e!<%H!#$3$l$,8+;v$K7h$^$C$F$D$$$K5UE>$7$?!#:#5(=i$NJ#?tF@E@$H$$$&2w5s$G$"$k!#8eH>DI2C;~4V$KFMF~$7!"$"$H(B1$BJ,$G;n9g=*N;$H(B
$B$$$&$H$3$m$@$C$?$N$K!#?@8M(BMF$BEOn5$K7h$a$i$l$FF1E@$K!#$"!<$"!#O"GT$O;_$a$?$b$N$N!">!Mx$O$*MB$1$H$J$C$F$7$^$C$?!#(B
$B!!9%D4$N?@8M$KE(CO$G0z$-J,$1$?$3$H$rA08~$-$KB*$($h$&!#!Mx$M!#(B
$BDm$N;(Ap$,$9$4$$!#%9%.%J$,$"$A$3$A$K=P8=$7!"%l%s%2$b2DNy$J2V$r:i$+$;$A$c$C$F$$$k!#K\F|$O!"$=$NE0Dl=|5n$K6P$7$s$@!#$^$:$O8<4X<~$j(B
$B$+$i!#%"%W%m!<%A$NN{4$$N7d4V$K@8$($F$$$kAp$r!"C0G0$KH4$-4/23
($BEZ(B) $B$N?JJb!!E]$l$??M$NJ,$^$GAv$k$N$,%5%C%+!<$@(B
$B%;%k%8%*1[8e$N8@MU!#K\F|$h$j!"F|5-$NI=Bj$r85$KLa$9!#A0$K?J$^$J$/$F$O$$$1$J$$$N$@!#(B
$B%Y%,%k%?@gBf%l%G%#!<%9(B 1-1 INAC$B?@8M%l%*%M%C%5!#:G=i$+$i!"8eH>$N$h$&$J@o$$$r$7$F$$$l$P!#(B
$B!!$$$D$bDL$j!"Mx5W$5$s$K$F5m%?%sDj?)$rD:$$$F$+$i!"%f%"%F%C%/%9%?%8%"%`@gBf$KF~$C$?!#%9%?%8%"%`$G$O!"7'K\CO?L$X$NJg6b3hF0$,9T$o$l$F$$$?!#(B
$B%l%G%#!<%9%8%e%K%"%f!<%9$NA*e$2$F$$$?!#:bI[(B
$B$r
$B!!;n9g$,;O$^$C$?!#?@8M$NA*ee$H$J$C$?!#2ZNo$K%\!<%k$r7R$,$l$F!"0lJ}E*$K96$a9~$^$l$F$7$^$C(B
$B$?!#@gBf%\!<%k$K$J$C$F$b!"(B10$BJ,$K!"%*%&%s%4!<%k$GAa!9$K<:E@!#@5D>!"$3$l$OBLL\$+$H;W$C$?!#$H$3$m$,(B
$B8eH>$K$J$k$H!"@8$^$lJQ$o$C$?$h$&$K@gBf$,96$a9~$_;O$a$?!#%O!<%U%?%$%`$K4FFD$K!"2?$r$S$S$C$F$$$k$s$@$HAjEv$K5$9g$$$rF~$l$i$l$?$i$7$$!#4FFD(B
$B[)$/!"$3$s$J$KE\$C$?$N$O=i$a$F$H$N$3$H$G$"$C$?!#3N$+$K!"!V?@8M!W$H$$$&L>$KB?$/$NA*(B37$BJ,!"(BDF$B:4!9LZ(B $BKzA*
$B!!A0H>$N$S$S$j$,$b$C$?$$$J$+$C$?!#$G$b!"$b$&!"$S$S$k$3$H$O$J$$$@$m$&!#(B2$B0L$r
4/22 ($B6b(B) $B!!L@F|$HL@8eF|$O?@8M@o(B
$B%Y%,%k%?@gBf%l%G%#!<%9$OL@F|!"%f%"%F%C%/%9%?%8%"%`@gBf$K(BINAC$B?@8M%l%*%M%C%5$r7^$(7b$D(B(13$B;~;n9g3+;O(B)$B!#(BINAC$B?@8M$HJ9$/$H$S$S$C$F(B
$B$7$^$&$,!"8=:_!"?@8M$O(B3$B0L$G2f$,%/%i%V$O(B2$B0L$G$"$k!#5nG/$N%(%-%5%$%F%#%s%0%7%j!<%:>e0L%j!<%0$G$O8+;v>!Mx$7$?Aj!Mx$7$h$&!#(B
$B!!CK;R$OL@8eF|!"%t%#%C%;%k?@8M$HE(CO$GF.$&(B(13$B;~;n9g3+;O(B)$B!#>e0L$H$NBP7h$,B3$$$?$3$H$b$"$j!"%j!<%0@o$r(B4$BO"GT$7$F$7$^$C$F$$$k2f$,%/%i%V(B
$B$G$"$k!#L@8eF|$OI,$:>!$?$J$$$H$$$1$J$$!#$=$7$F>e>:5$N.$K>h$m$&!#(B
$B%b%G%k$N2~NICf!#=gD4$K$$$C$F$$$k$H;W$C$?$i!"Ff$N7W;;7k2L$,=P$k$h$&$K$J$C$F$7$^$C(B
$B$?!#(B"2596148429267413814265248164610048"$B$C$F$$$&?t;z$O2?$@!)(B
$B@<$K=P$7$FFI$`$H!"(B25$B9B(B9614$B>w(B8429𥝱2674$BT6(B1381$B5~(B4265$BC{(B2481$B2/(B6461$BK|(B0048$B$G$"$k!#(B0$B0J>e(B1$B0J2<$NCM$7(B
$B$+$H$i$J$$HfN($N7W;;(B$B$r$7$F$$$k$N$K!"(B25$B9B(B9614$B>w(B8429𥝱2674$BT6(B1381$B5~(B4265$BC{(B2481$B2/(B6461$BK|(B0048
$B$@!#Lu$,$o$i$+$s!#(B
4/21 ($BLZ(B) $B!!
$B:rF|$N%d%^%6%-%J%S%9%3%+%C%W$N;n9g$O!"%Y%,%k%?@gBf(B0-0$B%"%S%9%QJ!2,$N0z$-J,$1$K=*$o$C$?!#>!$F$k;n9g$@$C$?$@$1$K2y$7$$!#$G$b!".Eg$H(BFW$B@>B-Mh$rGXIi$C$FM_$7$$A*.Eg!">eGX$O$J$$$N$K%X%C%I$,6/$$$M!#@>(B
$BB<$O!"4i$N$9$4$_$O$"$k$H;W$&!#@5D>$^$@$^$@$@$C$?$1$l$I!"$3$&$d$C$F7P83$r@Q$s$GHtLv$7$F$$$3$&!#(B
$B$J$N$h$A$c$s!&$^$7$c$+!&$A$c$s$+$_(B($B2>(B)$B$H0l=o$K!"$J$N$h$A$c$s$N%5%s%W%kC5$7$K9T$C$?!#%9%_%l?t/!9;D$C$F$$$?!#$b$C$A!<$ND4::CO$NJ}$K$b9T$C$F$_$?!#$H!"(B
$BNS>2$KCV$+$l$?4]B@$,A}$($F$$$?!#8O$lLZ$rH2:N$7$F4]B@$K$7!"NS>2$N$"$A$3$A$K@Q$_>e$2$F$$$k$N$@!#$*$$$*$$$H;W$C$FD4::CO$KC)$jCe$/$H!"4]B@$N(B
$B2
$B%b%G%k$N2~NICf!#COF;$K?J$`!#(B
4/20 ($B?e(B) $B!!D)@o
$B@8J*3X2J(B3$BG/@88~$1$N9V5A$r$7$?!#!V2V$N@8BV3X!W$H$$$&$*Bj$G$"$C$?!#=P@J$9$Y$-$J$N(B
$B$+!#(B
$B
$B8a8e$O!"%$%?%]%s!&$^$7$c$+$H0l=o$K9=Fb$r;6:v$7$?!#?"J*C5$7$J$j!#?"J*$O8+$D$+$C$?$1$l$I?"J*$O8+$D$+$i$J$+$C$?$H$$$&46$8$G$"$C$?!#(B
$B5(@a$r$:$i$7$FC5$7$F$_$h$&!#(B
$B%Y%,%k%?@gBf$O:#Lk!"%f%"%F%C%/%9%?%8%"%`@gBf$K%"%S%9%QJ!2,$r7^$(7b$D(B(19$B;~;n9g3+;O(B)$B!#%d%^%6%-%J%S%9%3%+%C%W$NM=A*%j!<%0$N@o$$(B
$B$G$"$k!#(BJ1$B%j!<%0$G$O@dITD4$J$,$i!"%d%^%6%-%J%S%9%3%+%C%W$G$O@d9%D4$N2f$,%/%i%V$G$"$k!#@5D>!"N>!$C$F!"7h>!%H!<%J%a%s%H?J=P$rL\;X$=$&!*(B
$B:#F|$b!"%b%G%k$K$D$$$F9M$($?!#%7%_%e%l!<%7%g%s$h$j$b$^$:$O!"$b$&(B1$BCJ3,J#;($K$7$?%b%G%k$r2r@O$7$F$_$k$Y$-$G$O$J$$$+!#$=$&;W$C$F;n(B
$B$_$k$b!">l9gJ,$1$N?t$,5^A}$7$F?4$,@^$l$F$$$k!#(B
4/19 ($B2P(B) $B!!%m%"%C%=7'K\(B
$B:rF|$^$?$7$F$bBg$-$JCO?L$,5/$-$?!#7'K\$N?I$$>u67$OB3$/!#(B
$B!!;d$H$7$F$O$d$O$j!"(BJ2$B$N%m%"%C%=7'K\$N$3$H$b?4G[$G$"$k!#A*u67$G$O$J$$$H$$$&!#B>%/%i%V$N;n9g(B
$B$O:#8e!"DL>oDL$j$K9T$o$l$k$G$"$m$&!#7'K\$N;n9g$@$1>C2=$5$l$J$$$H$J$k$H$I$&$J$C$F$7$^$&$N$+!#;n9g$,=PMh$k$h$&$K$J$C$?$i!"7'K\$@$1=5(B2$B;n9g(B
$B$r$3$J$7$F$$$/!)(B $B$=$l$O$"$^$j$KBgJQ$@!#%A%'%"%^%s$NAG@2$i$7$-2r7h:v$r4|BT$7$?$$!#(B
$B$J$N$h$A$c$s!&$^$7$c$+$HB48&$NAjCL$r$7$?!#$=$NJ}8~$G9T$3$&!*(B $B4hD%$C$FD:BW!#(B
$B%l%U%j!<$r$7$?!#%"%a%j%+?M$O5DO@$,>eeO$K$O!"!V!{!{$O!"A4BN$H$7$F$O8z2L$,$J$+$C$?!#$7$+$7(BA$B$H$$$&8BDj2<$G$O(B
$B8z2L$,$"$C$?!W$H=q$$$F$"$k!#9M;!$N>O$K9T$/$H!"$^$?$7$F$b!"8BDjE*$G$"$k$3$H$rL5;k$7$F!"!V!{!{$H$$$&6C$-$N8z2L$,$"$C$?!W$H5=!W$+!)(B
$B5W$7$V$j$K!"<+J,$N%b%G%k$N2r@O$r:F3+$7$?!#$O$?$7$F$3$l$G$h$$$N$+$I$&$+!#%7%_%e%l!<%7%g%s$,I,MW$J5$$,$9$k!#(B
$B$5!":#$+$i!"%l%]!<%H:n@.K!$N9V5A$K9T$C$F$/$k!#(B
4/18 ($B7n(B) $B!!3X@8
$B@8J*3X2J(B3$BG/@88~$1$K%"%*%-$N3X@8
$B!!:n6HFbMF$r@bL@$7$?8e!"l$N$=$P$NNS$K9T$C$?!#:rG/$^$G9T$C$F$$$?>l=j$,4]B@CV$->l$K$J$C$F$$$?$N$G!":#G/$+$i$O?7$7$$>l=j$G$"$k!#F;O)(B
$B$NK!LL$N$h$&$JNS$G!"F;O)$+$i8+DL$7$,NI$$J,!"C$($k=w;R$,(B2$BL>!#G$C$F$$$?!#$=$&$$$&$b$N$+!#$+$/$7$F!"=gD4$K:n6H$r=*$($?!#0l$D$NHI$@(B
$B$1!"%"%*%-$,B?$$$?$a!"$+$J$j$N;~4V$,$+$+$C$F$7$^$C$?!#(B
$B!!=*$o$C$?HI$O!"!uBV$G$"$C$?!#A4HI$N:n6H=*N;8e$K!";d$bo$K9%46$r;}$F$?!#(B
$B!!$=$l$K$7$F$b!#D4::$r9T$C$?>l=j$N1x$5$Kmd0W$7$?!#F;O)$+$iEj$2
4/17 ($BF|(B) $B!!>!$A$-$C$?(B
$B:#F|$O!"%Y%,%k%?@gBf%l%G%#!<%9$N1~1g$N$?$a$K?73c$K1s@,$9$k(B($BBP%"%k%S%l%C%/%9?73c%l%G%#!<%9(B)$B!#7'K\$N$3$H$r;W$$$?$a$i$$$b@8$8$?$1$l$I!"7P(B
$B:Q3hF0$rDdBZ$5$;$k$N$OL50UL#$@!#$$$D$bDL$j$K9TF0$7!"HyNO$J$,$i>CHq$7$h$&!#$H$$$&$o$1$G!"D+(B7$B;~H>$K
$B!!;n9g$,;O$^$C$?!#@gBf$,$d$d2!$75$L#$NE83+$G$"$C$?!#$7$+$77hDj5!$r:n$k$3$H$,$G$-$J$$!#A0H>(B30$BJ,$/$i$$$N!"?73c$N(BFK$B$N;~$@$C$?!#]>pJs$rEA$($i$l$?$h$&$@$C$?!#$=$7$F!"MnMk$N$?$a;n9gCfCG$H$J$C$?!#3N$+$K!"1s$/$NJ}$,0E$/$J$C$F$$$?!#$T$+$j$HA.8w$b8+$($?!#$3$l$+(B
$B$i$3$C$A(B $B$KMh$k$N$+!)(B
$B$d$,$F!"$9$5$^$8$$qe1+$,9_$j=P$7$?!#??$CGr$J1+E)$KA4LL$,Ho$o$l!"7J?'$,8+$($J$/$J$C$?!#$3$s$J1+!"8+$?$3$H$J$$$H$$$&46$8$G$"$k!#Iw$b@($^$8(B
$B$$!#$7$+(B
$B$7Mk$OMn$A$J$+$C$?!#(B20$BJ,$[$I$Gqe1+$,<}$^$C$?!#$=$N8e$7$P$i$/MM;R$r8+$?8e!";n9g$,:F3+$5$l$?!#6/Iw$OAjJQ$o$i$:!#$I$A$i$b7hDj5!$r:n$l$J$$(B
$B$^$^;~4V$,2a$.$F$$$/!#$=$7$F8eH>(B36$BJ,!"?73c$N%/%j%"%_%9$,!"%4!<%kA0$K$$$?@gBf(BFW$BM-D.(B
$B!Mx$7(B $B$?!#(B
$B!!0z$-J,$1$b$"$j$H;W$($?;n9g$r>!$A$-$C$?!#$3$&$d$C$F>!$A$re$7$?!#!(B
$BMx$7$F!"$5$i$K@*$$$K>h$m$&!*(B
4/16 ($BEZ(B) $B!!i,i/$O:i$/(B
$B7'K\$G$^$?Bg$-$JCO?L$,!#M>?L$+$H;W$$$-$d!"?7$?$J!VK\?L!W$G$"$k$i$7$$!#$J$s$H$$$&$3$H$+!#%K%e!<%9$GEA$($i$l$k8=CO$N>uBV$K$O!"?4$,=E$/$J$k(B
$B$P$+$j$G$"$k!#0lF|$G$bAa$$I|6=$r5'$j$D$D!#(B
$B!!(B5$BG/A0$r;W$$=P$7$J$,$iDm$K=P$?!#8<4X$r?6$jJV$C$F6C$$$?!#i,i/$,:i$$$F$$$k!#(B
$BNcG/$h$j$b(B1$B%v7nAa$$!#$^$@!"MU$,3+$$$?$P$+$j$H$$$&$N$K!#i,i/$O:i$/!#i,i/$O:i$/!#2V$O!!2V$O!!2V$O:i$/!#(B
$B"(:i$$$F$$$k$N$O$3$3$@$1!#<
$B:#F|$ODm;E;v$KNe$s$@!#$^$:$O!"uBV$K$J$C$F$$$?!#I|5l$5$;$h$&$H!"B]$r:o$j?H$KG@Lt$,$S$C$7$c$j$H$+$+$C$F$7$^$C$?!#?dDj(B2.5$B%j%C%H%k!#5c$1$?!#Ma<<$G@v$$N.$7:n6H$r:F3+!#$I(B
$B$&$K$+=*$($?!#Cn$,=P$?$i$O$C$?$*$9$+$i$M!#(B
$B%Y%,%k%?@gBf(B1-3$B1:OB%l%C%:!#E,CO$J$N$G(BCS$B$G1~1g$7$?!#NO$N:9$r8+$;$D$1$i$l$?;n9g$@$C$?!#1:OB$O!"967b$,2ZNo$J$@$1$G$O$J$$!#
$B!!$3$l$G(B4$BO"GT$7$F$7$^$C$?!#$=$N$&$A$N(B3$BGT$O:r5($K%Y%9%H(B3($B9-Eg!&Bg:e!&1:OB(B)$B$KBP$7$F$J$N$G!"$d$`$rF@$J$$$3$H$K$7$h$&!#(B
4/15 ($B6b(B) $B!!$*8+Iq$$(B
$BAa?2$J;d$OCN$i$J$+$C$?!#D+5/$-$F%F%l%S$r$D$1$k$H!"7'K\$G?LEY(B7$B$H$N2hLL$,!#0l=V!"ElF|K\Bg?L:R$,$^$?$7$F$b$H;W$C$?!#$=$7$F!"2-Fl$OBg>fIW$+(B
$B$H$$$&;W$$$bIb$+$s$@(B($B%^%D%O%7$,$$$k(B)$B!#MI$l$?CO0h$O8BDjE*$@$C$?$1$l$I!"7'K\$O?<9o$@!#?4$h$j$*8+Iq$$?=$7>e$2$^$9!#(B
$B%Y%,%k%?@gBf$OL@F|!"E(CO$G1:OB%l%C%:$HF.$&(B(14$B;~;n9g3+;O(B)$B!#8=:_!"%j!<%0@o(B3$BO"GTCf$N2f$,%/%i%V$G$"$k!#$=$3$X$h$j$K$h$C$F1:OB@o(B
$B$@!#$7$+(B $B$7!"$&$@$&$@8@$C$F$$$k>l9g$G$O$J$$!#:GDc$G$b>!$AE@(B1$B$r
$B!!%l%G%#!<%9$OL@8eF|!"E(CO$G%"%k%S%l%C%/%9?73c%l%G%#!<%9$HF.$&(B(13$B;~;n9g3+;O(B)$B!#E(CO$H$$$($I$bI,$:$d>!Mx$7$F
$B$"$*$d$J$HB48&$NAjCL$r$7$?!#J}?K$,8G$^$j!"%b%G%k$r:n$C$F$_$k$3$H$K$7$?!#$^$:$O;d$,!"(BMathematica$B$GD64JC1$J%W%m%0%i%`$r(B
$B=q$$$?!#$3$l$r$H$C$+$+$j$K!"(BMathematica$B$rJY6/$7$J$,$i%b%G%k$r:n$C$F$$$3$&$M!#(B
$B<+J,$N%b%G%k2r@O$b?J$a$?!#;n9T:x8m$N7k2L!"0-$/$J$$7k2L$,=P$FMh$?$h$&$J5$$,$9$k!#L\=PEY$7!#(B
4/14
($BLZ(B) $B$N?JJb!!%I%i%C%0%9%H%"(B
$B2f$,2H$N6a=j$K%I%i%C%0%9%H%"$,=PMh$?!#(B$B@dK>$N>]D'(B$B$G$"$k!#$3$3$K$O0JA0%9!<%Q!<$,$"$C$?!#2f$,2H$N=;BpCOM#0l$N%9!<%Q!<$G$"$C(B
$B$?!#$H$3$m$,JDE9$7$F$7$^$$!"7zJ*$Ol$K$J$C$F$$$?!#%9!<%Q!<$NI|3h$r4j$$!"2>$N;Q$G$"$k(B$B$H;W$$$?$$(B$BCs(B
$Bl$r8+$D$a$kF|!9$,B3$$$?!#9);v$,;O$^$C$?$N$G4|BT$7$?$i!"$J$s$H%I%i%C%0%9%H%"$K$J$C$F$7$^$C$?!#Lt0J30$K$b?'!907$C$F$$$kBgE9J^$J$N$G!"L5(B
$B$$$h$j$O$$$$$N$G$"$k$,(B $B!D!D!D!#$3$l$,=PMh$F$7$^$C$?$H$$$&$3$H$O!"%9!<%Q!<$NI|3h$,$J$/$J$C$?$H$$$&$3$H$G$"$m$&!#$h$C$F@dK>!#(B
$B!!$3$N%I%i%C%0%9%H%"$N(B20m$BNY$K!"8D?M7P1D$N>.$5$JLt6I$,$"$k!#Bg>fIW$+!#$5$i$K$O!"(B70m$B$N5wN%Fb$K>220$,(B3$B8.!"(B100m$B$N5wN%Fb$K%/%j!<%K(B
$B%s%020$,(B2$B8.$"$k!#$&!$l$,0[$J$k6H
$B6[5^B.Js!#@gBf;TH,LZ;3F0J*8x1`$+$i%A%s%Q%s%8!<$,C&Av$7$?!#(B2$B;~4V$"$^$j<+M3$rkp2N$7$?8e!"Kc?l=F$K$FJa3M$5$l$?$h$&$G$"$k!#(B
$B$^$7$c$+$HB48&$NAjCL!#$=$&!"Ev=i$NJ}8~@-$K94$kI,MW$O$J$$!#<+J,$,LLGr$$$H;W$&J}8~$X?J$a$P$h$$$N$@!#(B
$B@8J*3X2J(B3$BG/@88~$1$N9V5A$N=`Hw$r$7$?!#7k6I!"6LCn?'$NOC$r$9$k$N$O;_$a$?(B($B:rF|$N?JJb;2>H(B)$B!#$=$N$+$o$j!"<+?#$K$h$kJd=~$NOC$rI|3h$5(B
$B$;$?!#(B
4/13
($B?e(B) $B$N?JJb!!9V5A;O$^$k(B
$B@8J*3X2J(B3$BG/@88~$1$N9V5A$,;O$^$C$?!#K\F|$N=P@J
$B!!=i2s$H$$$&$3$H$G:#F|$O%$%s%H%m$r$7$?!#pw$-$J$,$iJ9$$$F$/$l$k3X@8$5$s$,2??M$+$$$F?46/$+$C$?!#Mh=5$+$i!"K\3JE*$K;O$a$k$+$i$M!#(B
$B
$BMh=5$N9V5A$N=`Hw$r?J$a$?!#%^%s%M%j$O$h$/$J$$!#Cf?H$rJQ$($F?7A/$K$7$J$$$H!#$=$&0U5$9~$_!"(B$B%&%1A@$$$N?7%M%?$r$^$:$O9M$($k(B$B$N(B
$B$O!"8+$D$a$F$$$kJ}8~$H$7$F@5$7$$$N$+!#(B
$B!!$=$N8e$O!"9V5A$G>R2p$9$k?7J88%$r??LLL\$KC5$7$?!#$H!"6LCn?'$N2V$K4X$9$kO@Ah$r8+$D$1$F$7$^$C$?(B(der Kooi et al.
(2014) $BBP(B Vignolini et al. (2014))$B!#(BWhitney et al.
(2009)$B$,!"6LCnH/?'$,K,2V:+Cn$NM60z$K8z$$$F$$$k$H$$$&O@J8$r=P$7$?!#6LCnH/?'$H$O!"(BCD$B$N$h$&$K!"8+$k3QEY$K$h$C$F8w$jJ}$,JQ$o$kH/?'$G(B
$B$"$k!#2h(B
$B4|E*$JH/8+$H467c$7$F!"9V5A$G>R2p$7$F$-$?$N$@$,!D!D!D!#6LCnH/?'$NB8:_$rH]Dj$9$kO@J8$,=P$F!"O@Ah$K$J$C$F$$$k$i$7$$!#N>$B$5$9$,6LCn?'$NO@Ah(B$B$G$"$k!#6LCnH/?'$r!"9V5A$G>R2p$9$Y$-$+(B
$B$d$a$k$Y$-$+!#G:$`!#(B
4/12
($B2P(B) $B$N?JJb!!9V5A$N=`Hw(B
$BL@F|$+$i!"@8J*3X2J(B3$BG/@88~$1$N9V5A$,;O$^$k!#K\F|!"9V5A$N7W2h$rN}$C$?!#$^$:$O!":rG/$N9V5A%"%s%1!<%H$r=87W$7!"LLGr$_$K7g$1$?OCBj!"M}2r$7$K(B
$B$/$+$C$?OCBj$r8+$F$$$C$?!#;d$N0u>]$G$O!"!V:GE,@oN,$H%2!<%`M}O@!W$N2A$,NI$/!"!V?"J*$K$*$1$k@-I=8=!W$NJ}$,$7$F$_$?!#>/!9?t<0$O=P$FMh$F$$$k$,(B $B!D!D!D!#$H$b$+$/!"$b$C$H$o$+$j$d$9$/$9$k$h$&4hD%$m$&!#(B
$B!!:#G/$O!"!V<+2HITOB9g@-$N?J2=!W$H$$$&?7OCBj$b9V5A$9$k!#(B
Sakai, S. (2016) How have self-incompatibility haplotypes
diversified? Generation of new haplotypes during the evolution of
self-incompatibility from self-compatibility. American
Naturalist in press.
Sakai, S. and Wakoh, H. (2014) Initial invasion of
gametophytic self-incompatibility alleles in the absence of tight
linkage between pollen and pistil S alleles. American
Naturalist 184:248-257.
$B$H!"$9$C$+$j!"<+2HITOB9g@-$O$+$;(B$B4A;z$NGn;N$G$O$J$$$H$3$m$,=EMW(B$B$K$J$C$?46$,$"$k$N$G!";d$N:G?7$N8&5f$rCf?4$K(B
$B>R2p$9$k$N$@!#:#G/EY$N9V5A%"%s%1!<%H$G$3$NOCBj$NI>H=$,0-$+$C(B $B$?$i$b$&<+?.AS<:!#(B
$B>eB<7/$HB48&%F!<%^$NOC$r$7$?!#J}8~@-$,8+$($F$-$?!#$+$?$d!"!V8cGZ$O>eB<$G$"$k!#^UL>$O$^$@L5$$!W$J$N$G$"$k!#(B
$B=$N;@8$N%R%i%,$+$i?48/$$$,FO$$$?!#$I$&$b$"$j$,$H$&!#2f$,2H$G$N4?7^2q$GD:$-$^$9!#$=$l$K$7$F$b!"4/11
($B7n(B) $B$N?JJb!!3X@8
$B?73X4|$H$J$C$?!#:#F|$O!"M}3XIt@8J*3X2J(B3$BG/@8$rBP>]$K!"%+%?%/%j$N3X@8$BE7$W(B
$B$i$K$7$F6t$C$A$^$C$?(B$B$N$G!"NI?4$,$A$g$C$H2W$^$l$?(B(4/9$B$N?JJb(B$B;2>H(B)$B!#$=$s$J;d$N?4$bCN$i(B
$B$:!"3X@8$OG.?4$K:n6H$K
$B$J$N$h$A$c$sI.!V%+%?%/%j2rBN3(?^!W!#4J7i$K$7$FMW$rF@$?$j!#?tI4G/;D$l$P9qJu$H$J$k$G$"$m$&$,!"C$7$F$7$^$C(B
$B$?!#(B
$B=8CfNO$NMW$k:n6H$G$"$C$?$,!"$_$J:,5$$h$/$d$C$F$/$l$?!#$*Hh$lMM$G$7$?!#(B
$B!!$J$N$h$A$c$s$H$^$7$c$+$,
$B8aA0Cf$O!">eB<7/$N$3$H$K$D$$$F9M$($?!#!V(B$B8F$SL>$r(B$B!W$H;W$C$?J}$O4/10
($BF|(B) $B$N?JJb!!6lGU(B
$B%Y%,%k%?@gBf(B1-3$B%,%s%PBg:e!#$^$?$7$F$b!"O"B3<:E@$N0-JJ$,!#(B
$B!!;n9g$O8a8e$+$i!#8aA0Cf$O!"@>MNJ,$/$i$$$,Aa$/$bNP$K$J$C$F$$$k!#$3$ND4;R$G!"0lF|$bAa(B
$B$/A0LLNP$K$J$k$h$&$K!#$+$?$d!";(Ap$b$43hLv$G$"$k!#$D$$$K%9%.%J$N;Q$b8+$F$7$^$$!"$*$(!<$C$H$J$C$?$N$G$"$C$?!#(B
$BNc$K$h$C$F!"Mx5W$5$s$G5m%?%sDj?)$rD:$$$F$+$i%f%"%F%C%/%9%?%8%"%`@gBf$KF~$C$?!#:#F|$O$A$g$C$HH)4($$!#$J$I$H;W$C$F$$$?A0H>(B5$BJ,$K(B
$BAa!9$K<:E@$7$F$7$^$C$?!#(BGK$B@P@n$,!"CfESH>C<$KA0$K=P$F$7$^$C$?!#<:E@$9$k$H!"5$;}$A$,Mn$A$k$N$+!"N)$FB3$1$K<:E@$9$k$N$,$3$N:"$N2f$,%/%i%V(B
$B$G$"$k!#:#F|$bNc$K$b$l$:$G!"A0H>(B14,
16$BJ,$K$b<:E@!#Aa$/$b(B0-3$B$K$J$C$F$7$^$C$?!#A0H>(B27$BJ,$K(BFW$B%&%#%k%=%s$,(BPK$B$r7h$a$F(B1-3$B$K!#$=$N8e!"%3!<%J!<%-%C%/$+$i%M%C%H$rMI$i$9(B
$B$b%*%U%5(B
$B%$%I$NH=Dj$G$"$C$?!#$&!e$,$C$?$N$K!#$=$l$G$b8eH>$O!"@gBf$,0lJ}E*$K96$a$F!"I,;`$NDI7b$r8+$;$F$/$l$?!#$H$3(B
$B$m$,%4!<%k$,1s$$!#@:EY$NDc$5$b$"$C$?$1$l$I!"$D$$$F$$$J$$=j$b$"$C$?!#7k6I!"DI7bE@$rC%$&$3$H$J$/(B1-3$B$GGT$l$F$7$^$C$?!#(B
$B!!(B15$B0L$KE>Mn$7$F$7$^$C$?!#%+%C%W@o$r4^$a(B8$B;n9g$r@o$$!"J#?tF@E@$N;n9g$J$7$G$"$k!#$&!
4/9 ($BEZ(B)
$B$N?JJb!!2w>!(B
$B%Y%,%k%?@gBf%l%G%#!<%9(B3-0$B%8%'%U%f%J%$%F%C%I;T86!&@iMU%l%G%#!<%9!#2w>!$@$C$?!#(B
$B!!;n9g$O3QED;T$G9T$o$l$k!#$A$g$C$HAa$a$K(B9$B;~2a$.$K2H$r=P$?!#(B11$B;~2a$.$KE~Ce!#%a%s%P!<30$NA*^IJ$rL\;X$7$FD)$s$G$_$?!#7k2L$O$&$^$$K@(B1$BK\$G$"$C$?!#$3$&$$$&J*$O?)$Y$J$$$N$G!"NY$N%V!<%9$K$$$?(BMF$B:4!9LZ(B
$BH~OBA*
$B!!;n9g$,;O$^$C$?!#N)$A>e$,$j$+$i!"@gBf$,$[$H$s$I;YG[$9$kE83+$H$J$C$?!#$=$7$FA0H>(B11$BJ,!"%3!<%J!<%-%C%/$+$i(BMF$B@nB<(B
$BM%M}A*(B38$BJ,!"$&$^$/H4$1=P$7$?(BFW$BIMED(B
$BMZA*l$H$J$C$?!#8rBXOH$r;H$$2L$?$7$F$$$?(B
$B$N$G!"@i(B $BMU(BDF$B]/K\A*!Ii$"$j$@$C$?!#DI2C;~4V$K$O!"(BFW$B0BK\(B
$Be$2$?!#
$B!!NI$$;n9g$@$C$?!#6l!Mx$r@Q$_=E$M$h$&!#(B
$B:rF|$N5"$j$KD+;T$K4s$C$?!#$J$s$H!"%+%?%/%j$rGd$C$F$$$?!#%Q%C%/$K!"CO>eIt$,(B20$BK\$[$I!#$D$$$D$$Gc$C$F$-$F!"E7$W$i$K$7$F$_$?!#2V(B
$BJ[!&h`!&;s$7$Y$,$=$N$^$^$G!"$J$s$+%0%m%F%9%/$G$"$C$?!#L#$b!"$9$k$s$@$+$7$J$$$s$@$+$H$$$&46$8$@$C$?!#(B
4/8 ($B6b(B)
$B$N?JJb!!L@F|$O@iMU@o!"L@8eF|$OBg:e@o!#(B
$B%Y%,%k%?@gBf%l%G%#!<%9$OL@F|!"%8%'%U%f%J%$%F%C%I;T86!&@iMU%l%G%#!<%9$r3QED;TN&>e6%5;>l$K7^$(7b$D(B(13$B;~;n9g3+;O(B)$B!#A0@aGT$l$F$7$^$C$?2f(B
$B$,%/%i%V$G$"$k!#%[!<%`$J$N$@$7I,$:>!$C$F!"@*$$$K>h$m$&!#(B
$B!!CK;R$OL@8eF|!"%,%s%PBg:e$r%f%"%F%C%/%9%?%8%"%`@gBf$K7^$(7b$D(B(14$B;~;n9g3+;O(B)$B!#(B2$B>!(B3$BGT$H:#$R$H$DGH$K>h$l$J$$2f$,%/%i%V$G$"$k!#$+$?$d(B
$BBg:e$bK\D4;R$G$O$J$$!#$h$C$F>!Mx$7!"2f$,%/%i%V$NJ}$,GH$K>h$m$&!#(B
$B?7G/EY:G=i$NCLOC2q$,$"$C$?!#?7B48&@8(B4$B?M$b@5<0$K;22C$7$F$/$l$?!#;d$d@hGZ$HOC$r$7$D$D!"$=$7$F<+J,$N%"%$%G%#%"$r@Q6KE*$K=P$7$F!"B4(B
$B6H8&5f$N%F!<%^$r8G$a$F$$$C$FD:BW!*(B
$B!!3'$,@Q6KE*$KH/8@$7$F$/$l$F!"=<e$2$F$$$C$FM_$7$$!#(B
$B%b%G%k2r@O!#:rF|$N0l6Z$N8wL@$rMj$j$K2~NI$7$?$b$N$N!">.$BBg$7$FLLGr$/$J$$$3$H$,$7$P$7$P(B$B$G$"$k(B
$B$,!#(B
4/7 ($BLZ(B)
$B$N?JJb!!2qOC$,B3$/(B
$B:rF|$N%+%?%/%j$NA[A|2qOC$NB3JT!#(B
$B;6:v
$B;6:v
$B;6:veAX$NeIt$,$J$/$J$k=U?"J*$G!"(B5$B7n2<=\$K!<%`$,IU$$$F$$$k?"J*$G$9$+!)!W(B
$B;6:v
$B$H$$$&2qOC$,(B$B8+$:CN$i$:$N?M$N4V$G@.N)(B$B$7$?$i!"$=$NEZCO!"5$7Z$K;6:v$G$-$J$$5$$,$9$k!#$H$$$&$o$1$G!"$7$s$9$1$h$j$ND{@5>pJs$G$7(B
$B$?!#$I$&$b$"$j$,$H$&!#(B
$B$"$*$d$J!&$^$7$c$+$HB48&$NAjCL!#Fs?M$H$b!"4hD%$C$FO@J8$rFI$s$G$$$k!#$3$ND4;R$G!*(B
$B%b%G%k$K$D$$$F9M$($?!#Ev$?$jA0$N7k2L$H$$$&$+!"LLGr$_$,$J$$$H$$$&$+!#Le!9$H$9$k$3$H$7$P$7!#5"$j:]$K!"0l6Z$N8wL@$r$h$&$d$/;W$$$D$$(B
$B$?!#(B
4/6 ($B?e(B)
$B$N?JJb!!IaDLJ*(B
$B:#F|$b$b$C$A!<$ND4::$KIU$$$F$$$C$?!#$"$*$d$J!&$^$7$c$+$K$bMh$FLc$C$?!#D4::CO$N$"$A$3$A$KH2:N$7$?4]B@$,@Q$^$l$F$*$j!"%S%K!<%kB^$GHo$o$l$F(B
$B$$$?!#%S%K!<%k$N2<$KH2:NF|!&6H
$B$H$3$m$,!"Cm0U=q$-(B($B!v(B)$B$NBP>]$,8+Ev$?$i$J$$!#!VFG7`J*$K3:Ev$7$J$$$b$N$r;X$7$F$$$&DL>N!W$H$O$$$C$?$$2?$+!)(B $B!V0BA4J*!W!VHsFG7`J*!W!)!)(B
$B?"J*D4::$KMh$?$N$K!"M>7W$J$3$H$KG:$s$G$7$^$C$?!#Le!9$H$7$D$D!"%+%?%/%j$NMM;R$b8+$K9T$C$?!#=*$o$j$+$1$N2V$b$"$C$?!#%+%?%/%j$N$B$3$Ne:No$J$*2V$O2?$G$9$+!)(B$B!W$HJ9$-$?$/$J$C$?!#!V%+%?%/%j$C$F8@$&$s$G$9!W$K!"(B$B!VCOCf(B30$B%;%s%A(B
$B$/$i$$$N$H$3$m$KCO2<7T$,$"$j!"MU$,(B2$BKg$K$J$k$H3+2V$7!"M:@-@h=O$G<+2HOB9g@-$G!"3+2V4|4V$O(B13$BF|$/$i$$$G!"2VJ4$NAwJ4$K$O3+2V4|4V$$$C$Q(B
$B$$$+$+$k$N$K!"fueAX$NeIt$,$J$/$J$k=U?"J*$G!"(B5$B7n2<=\$K!<%`$,IU$$$F$$$k?"J*$G$9$+!)!W(B$B$HJ9$-JV$7$?$i$I$&H?1~$J$5$k$+!#(B
$B!!8&5f<<$KLa$j!"!VFG7`J*$K3:Ev$7$J$$$b$N$r;X$7$F$$$&DL>N!W$G8!:w$7$F$_$?!#Ez$($O!VIaDLJ*!W$G$"$C$?!#FG7`$G$J$$$b$N$OIaDL$H$O!"4V$,Ht$S$9(B
$B$.$F(B $B$$$J$$$+!#(B
$BK\F|$OF~3X<0$J$j!#$=$N8e!"@8J*3X2J?7F~@88~$1$N%*%j%(%s%F!<%7%g%s$b$"$C$?!#?"J*@8BV8&5f<<$N>R2p$r(B2$BJ,$[$IC}$C$?!#(B
$B%b%G%k2r@O$r?J$a$?!#7W;;$7$F$_$?$H$3$m!"$"$^$j$K$bEv$?$jA0$N7k2L$,=P$Fh+MN$H$7$F$$$k!#$b$C$H$b$C$H9)IW$7$J$$$H$$$1$J$$!#(B
4/5 ($B2P(B)
$B$N?JJb!!=EHG(B3$B$D(B
$B!V(B$B$3$l$+$i%l%]!<%H!&B4O@$r=q$/$B!W$N(B9$B2sL\$N=EHG$H!"!V(B$B$3$l$+$i3X2qH/I=$9$k$B!W$N(B7$B2sL\$N=EHG$H!"!V(B$B$3$l$+$i8&5f$r;O$a$k9b9;@8$H;XF3650w$N$?$a$K!'8&5f$N?J$aJ}!&O@J8$N=q$-J}!&8}F,$H%]%9(B
$B%?!$B!W$N(B2$B2sL\$N=EHG$,7h$^$C$?!#0l5s$K(B3$B:}$b=EHG$H$J$C$F4r$7$$!#$*Gc$$>e$2!"@?$K$"$j$,$H$&$4$6$$$^$9!#(B
$B!!$3$l%l%]=EHG$G!"%A!<%`%$%s%H%m$N%a%s%P!<8rBe$b40N;$7$?!#%$%s%H%m$N(B5$B$D$N9|;R$O!"D9$$4V!"!V2?$rA0$K$7$F!W!V$I$&$$$&LdBj$K$B%A!<%`(BA$B!&%A!<%`(BB
$B$J$I$H3FK\FH<+$N%A!<%`$r;}$D(B$B$N$b$h$$$+$H;W$C$?$,!"FIe$,$C$?$j$O$7(B
$B$J$$$G$"$m$&!#$=$3$G!"B>$NK\$G$b%a%s%P!<8rBe$9$Y$/!"=EHG$N$?$S$K=q$-49$($F$$$?!#$3$l3X!&$3$l8&$G$N8rBe$O:rG/=*$($?!#$=$7$F:#2s!"$3$l%l%](B
$B$G$b%a%s%P!<8rBe$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$?!#$H$$$&$o$1$G!"%A!<%`%$%s%H%m!V2?$rA0$K$7$F!W!V$I$&$$$&LdBj$K$h$m$7$/!*(B
$B$b$C$A!<$HJ`>l$r;6Jb!#$b$&L5$/$J$C$F$$$k!)(B
$B%b%G%k2r@O$r?J$a$?!#%P%0$OL5$/$J$C$?(B($B$?$V$s(B)$B!#7W;;$r4/4 ($B7n(B)
$B$N?JJb!!BgJQ$J$3$H$K$J$C$?(B
$B%Y%,%k%?@gBf$K6[5^;vBV$G$"$k!#(BGK$B4X(B $B7{B@O:A*$B%Y(B
$B%,%k%?8x<0%Z!<%8(B$B$h$j(B)$B!#@5(BGK$B$NO;H?$,2x2f$GN%C&$7$?$?$a!"BX$o$C$F%4!<%k$rl7P83$,$J$$@P@n$G$"$k$,!"9%5!$HG3$((B
$B$?$.$C$F(B $BM_$7$$!#(B
$B?73X4|$H$J$j!"?7B48&@8$b8&5f<<$KDL$$=P$7$F$$$k!#NI$$46$8$@!#4hD%$C$F!"LLGr$$8&5f$r$7$h$&!#(B
$B!!>eB<7/$H$b!"Bh0l2s$NB48&AjCL$r$7$?!#$=$NK5$i!"8F$SL>$N$3$H$r5$$K$7$F$$$k;d$G$"$C$?!#9b9;;~Be!"!V$+$_!W$H8F$P$l$?$3$H$,$"$k$H$$$&OC$b=P(B
$B$?!#$7$+$7!"8eGZ$,F~$C$?$H$-$K!V$+$_$5$s!W$H8F$P$l$k$H$9$k$H!"7I$o$l$F$$$k46$8$K$J$i$J$$$N$GNI$/$J$$!#(B
$B%b%G%k2r@O$r?J$a$?!#@h=5Kv$K$@$s$^$j$H$J$C$F$7$^$C$?860x$O!"L5BL$KJ#;($J%b%G%k$K$7$?$?$a$G$"$k!#$b$C$HC1=c$J2>Dj$G==J,$H5$$E$$(B
$B$?!#C1=c%b%G%k$X$N2~NI$r;n$_$?$H$3$m!"C1=c$J$j$K%P%0$,=P$k!#G:$^$7$$$C$?$i$"$j$c$7$J$$!#(B
4/3 ($BF|(B)
$B$N?JJb!!62N5E8(B
$B:#F|$O5"$k$@$1$G$"$k!#>eLn$N2J3XGnJ*4[$G62N5E8$r$d$C$F$$$k$N$G!"$;$C$+$/$@$+$i8+$K9T$C$F$_$?!#?M$,B?$/$FBgJQ$@$C$?$1$l$I!"LLGr$+$C$?!#2~(B
$B$a$F!"B?MM$J@8J*$r:n$j=P$9?J2=$N$9$4$5$K46LC$9$k!#?J2=@8J*3X$B%Y%,%k%?@gBf%l%G%#!<%9(B1-2$B2,;3Er6?%Y%k!#:#F|$N(B13$B;~$+$iE(CO$G9T$o$l$?!#1GA|$,L5$$$N$G7HBS$G7P2a$rDI$C$?!#:r5($OBg>!B3$-$@$C$?(B
$BAj4/2 ($BEZ(B)
$B$N?JJb!!(B13$B2s4w(B
$BJl$N(B13$B2s4w$N$?$a$K>.ED86$K9T$C$?!#$=$7$F!"7;IWIX$HIq$A$c$sIWIX$H$GK!;v$r$7$?!#=*N;8e$O!"2q@JNAM}$N1&5~$5$s$G?);v$r$7$?!#1&5~$5$s$KMh$?(B
$B$N$O$B$+$/$$$&;d$b!"IM>>$K9T$C$F!"2{@PNAM}$N$$$CLZ$5$s$K$*;R!&:yBd$J$I!"=U$N?):`$r$U$s$@$s$K;H$C$?NAM}$r4.G=$7$?!#$$$D$bDL$j$H$F$bH~L#$G$"$C$?!#(B
$B!!$4F$-4o$r2<$+$i>e$K>e(B
$B$2$FMq$r2!$7=P$9$h$&$K$7!"$=$N=V4V$K:ZH$$G$/$k$j$H2s$9!#$D$^$j$O!"Mq$r>e$K>e$2$k$H$-$K:ZH$$G2s$9!"$H;W$C$F$$$?$N$G$"$k$,(B
$B!D!D!D!D!D!#$J$s$H!"Mq$r2<$K2<$2$k$H$-$K:ZH$$G2s$9$N$@$H$$$&!#Mq>F$-4o$r2<$K2<$2$k;~!"Mq$H$N4V$K0l=V7d4V$,=PMh$k!#$=$3$K:ZH$$rF~$l$A$g$s(B
$B$HFM$-=P(B $B$9$N$@$=$&$@!#$^$5$K!"$o$*!
4/1 ($B6b(B)
$B$N?JJb!!:#Lk$O9-Eg@o(B
$B%Y%,%k%?@gBf$O:#Lk!"E(CO$G%5%s%U%l%C%A%'9-Eg$HF.$&(B(19:30$B;n9g3+;O(B)$B!#:rG/2&h$l$F$$$J$$!#:#$NFb$K>!$C$F$7(B
$B$^$$=g0L$r>e$2$h$&!#(B
$B2J3X8&5fHq$,DL$C$?!*(B $B4r$7$$!#4hD%$C$F$h$$@.2L$r=P$9$>!#(B
$B:#F|$b$b$C$A!<$ND4::$KIU$$$F$$$C$?!#M[$,$B3X@8$,(B$B4hD%$C$FD4(B
$B::$r$7$?!#(B
$B!!D4::CO$^$G!"?eF;;\@_OF$ND>EP3,CJ$r1}I|$7$?!#D4::CO$N$"$kC+Dl$^$G0l5s$K(B350$BCJ$N3,CJ$G9T$/$N$@!#2<$j$O3Z$A$s!#$7$+$7EP$j$O(B
$B$7$s$I$$!#2?3,7z$F$N%S%k$KAjEv$9$k$N$@$m$&$H;W$$$J$,$iBQ$($?!#(B
$B%b%G%k$N2~NI$K6P$7$s$@!#$h$&$d$/$K$7$F!"K>$`7k2L$,=P$F$/$k$?$a$N80$,8+$($F$-$?!#$3$&$$$&2>Dj$rF~$l$l$P$&$^$/$$$/$@$m$&!#$=$&;W$C(B
$B$F(BMathematica$B%W%m%0%i%`$r2~NI$7!"7W;;$r$5$J$$$H$$$1$J$$!#(B
$BL@F|$OK!;v$G>.ED86$K9T$/!#Aa$$$b$N$G$b$&(B13$B2s4w$G$"$k!#=*N;8e$ONc$K$h$C$FIM>>$K9T$-!"$*5$$KF~$j$N2{@PNAM}E9!V$$$CLZ!W$5$s$K9T(B
$B$/!#K!;v$N8e$NCk?)$K$b2{@PNAM}$rD:$/$N$G!"$J$s$H$blTBt$JF|$H$J$k!#(B